We strive to make every cake fabulous here at Bear Heart Baking Company!  We Love to hear how we are doing from our Customers and would love to hear about your experience with our company!  You can find some of our Customers Comments here.

Winnie the Pooh Super Sleuth Birthday Cake

My Friends Tigger and Pooh Birthday Cake!

Dear Amy,

The cake was wonderful and my son absolutely loved it. The cake was yummy and decorated perfectly! Jayden has been running up to it for 2 days now picking off the fondant balls and eating them.  Everyone at the party couldn’t stop talking about how beautiful it was.  I have enclosed some pics of Jayden with the cake.  Everyone who has seen the pics on facebook has commented on the cake and how amazing it is. Can’t wait to have you create another masterpiece for our next special occassion!

Thanks again!

Jennifer and Jayden

Oxford, PA

Birthday Cake R2D2 from Star Wars

Star Wars R2D2 Birthday Cake


This is my happy 5 year-old with his cake. He was very surprised when he saw it and actually thought it was a stuffed animal!   We were pleased that he actually let us cut it and eat it, too.  Thank you so much for providing us all with this wonderful birthday memory and a one-of-a-kind cake.  Thanks again and good luck with your business!   We will keep you in mind for our future baking needs!


York, PA

16th Birthday Purple and Black Circle Birthday Cake

16th Birthday Purple and Black Circle Cake

Thank you soooooo much for our beautiful black and purple cake. My daughter was delighted with all of her friends comments about the beautiful cake at her sweet 16 party. It was a hit and a great conversational piece!


Columbia, PA

Purple Fairy Cake

Purple Fairy Cake

Hi Amy,

I have to tell you the fairy cake was a HUGE hit at my step-mom’s birthday!!  When I walked in the door with the cake, her face light up instantly! My step-mom is from the Philadelphia area and she’s used to the homemade goodness from the bakeries around there.   So when she said the cake was homemade and so good, I knew it was a winner. I wish I would have known about you sooner for my wedding cake in June, I spent close to $500 for a 3-tier small cake and it was dry and made from a box.

Thank you again and I’ll be contacting you soon for my husband’s birthday cake for the beginning of January. =)


York, PA

The Tax Collector Money Cake

Tax Collector Birthday Cake

Good morning!   Hope you had a nice Holiday weekend.  The cake was a huge hit.  Everyone loved it especially my mother-in-law.   She wouldn’t cut it right away.   She had to let it sit so she could admire it for awhile.  She was very thrilled that we did that for her.   Thank you again for making our vision a reality.


Jacobus, PA

Birthday Cake Delivery to Yorktowne Hotel York, PA

Yorktowne Hotel in York, PA 40th Birthday Cake delivery!


Thank you so much!  When we got back to the room after the wine dinner the cake was waiting.   My wife absolutely loved the look of the cake and also how it tasted.   Thank you so much for taking care of it on short notice and also for making sure it was delivered to the hotel on time.   That is great customer service!  It was truly a memorable experience for my wife’s 40th and it was a great way to celebrate for both of us!



West Virginia

Waterfall Birthday Cake for Brazil trip students

Waterfall Birthday Cake for a Brazillian themed Birthday!

I want to thank you tremendously for your great customer service and great cake!  Not only did the cake have bronze and beauty, it tasted fabulous!!  We were so thankful and impressed that you could accomodate us like that within such a short time period (less than 16 hours).   Your creativity is amazing!  I am definitely telling my friends and family about your business and wish you the best of luck!!


East Berlin, PA

Pink and Green Polka Dot Birthday Cake

Pinka nd Green Polka Dot Birthday Cake

 Dear Amy~
My daughter Libby loved loved her birthday cake.  I can not say enough good things about the ease of ordering this cake and how you translated my short emails into exactly what she was dreaming about!  The delivery and set up was on time and perfect in everyway but most importantly was the way my daughter’s eyes lit up when she saw the cake.   Thank you so very kindly!

Gettysburg, PA

Roulette Wheel Birthday Cake

Roulette Wheel Cake for a Vegas themed Birthday Party

Everyone loved the cake!   They were very impressed with the design and the flavor.

Sincere Thanks!


York, PA

Mod Monkey Birthday Cake

Mod Monkey 1st Birthday Cake

Good afternoon Amy.  I just wanted to let you know after a trying weekend of weather causing change in party date and change in location, Jensen’s first birthday party turned out wonderful.  We received rave reviews on both the cake and the cupcakes. The monkey was the cutest and matched the decorations perfectly.  It was exactly what I had envisioned.   You may actually be receiving a call from one of our relatives to order a 30th birthday cake in the shape of a Dooney & Bourke purse as they were so impressed.  All party guests absolutely loved the red velvet cake and we had multiple comments stating it was the moistest cake they’ve ever had, and I completely agree.

 Before I had my son I never thought I’d be one of those mothers that went completely overboard for things such as birthday parties.  But now that he’s here I realize things like 1st birthdays are cherished memories worth going overboard, and your cake/cupcakes made the party and memories only that much better.

 We will be ordering from you again.

Thank you,


York, PA

Black and White Cake

Black and White Cake

Hi Amy,

Your cake was a hit!!  Everybody loved it.  And somehow, we were able to pull off the surprise.  My daughter had no idea.  The evening was a great success.

 Thanks again for your beautiful addition to Sada’s party.  It helped make the night even more special.


York, PA

Welcome to the Nest Baby Shower Cake and Cupcakes

"Welcome to the Nest" Baby Shower Cake

I wanted to send you a personal note to let you know how much everyone LOVED your cakes.  They were not only beautiful but they were delicious too!  Everyone raved about the cakes, and of course as the hostess, I couldn’t have been happier with my decision to have BearHeartbakery make them!  Not only did you interpret my ideas accurately and beautifully, but people couldn’t stop commenting on how delicious BOTH cake flavors were. The blackraspberry filling was to die for and the carrot cake was scrumptious!  The only complaint I have is that they were so good I found it impossible to stick to my diet! 
Thank you again.  I will recommend BearHeartBakery to everyone I know.

Dover, PA

Confirmation Cake

3 tier Confirmation Cake!

Hi Amy,

The party went great and everyone was so impressed with the cake. You were right, the black was better. I was very happy that the cake also tasted fantastic! There was plenty for people to take home as well, and boy did they take the extra cake!  I am glad you could help us. I only took pictures of the cake. I honestly was so busy being hostess that I missed  the cookie tray. People ate them so fast. I only saw kids running with them and eating them as fast as they could.

Best Wishes,Lila

York, PA

York College Birthday Cake Delivery Service York PA Bakery

Shopping inspired Girly Birthday Cake Delivery to York College of Pennsylvania

“Hi Amy, 


Thank you for the beautiful cake….It was all that you said it would be and more.  My daughter was surprised and happy to see a beautiful birthday cake arrive at her college dorm for her 21st Birthday.  She had no idea what I was sending her.  When I spoke with her over the phone she said the cake was absolutely beautiful and delicious.  We both were very impressed and what was really impressive was the color and design of the cake.  It was so beautiful you don’t even want to cut it.  I thank you for assisting me in bringing my Baby some love & happiness from me through you for her 21st Birthday.”
New York


Mod Monkey Cake 2nd Birthday

Mod Monkey Birthday Cake for Mason

 I recently ordered the Mod Monkey birthday cake for my son’s 2nd birthday.  Everyone loved the design and especially loved the marshmellow fondant.  Each of the guest were really impressed by the cake flavor and the cake was a huge hit to end the birthday party.  I will definatley order another cake from this bakery and I will be telling others about your bakery.  Thanks again Amy, you did a wonderful job!
Dover, PA